Quiz: Off-the-shelf SaaS or custom software?
Buy an off-the-shelf SaaS solution or build one from scratch? This is one of the most important technology decisions for a company. Answer our 7 questions about competitive advantage, budget, time, IT team and integrations - and we'll help you choose the path with the best ROI.
Quiz: off-the-shelf SaaS or custom software
Question 01 / 07 · Competitive edge
Is software key to your competitive advantage?
If software IS your product, custom gives you a unique edge.
Buy vs Build - one of the most important technology decisions in a company
"Buy an off-the-shelf SaaS solution or build from scratch?" - is a question that business owners, CTOs and IT directors face. The wrong answer costs money. Implementing a SaaS too quickly that doesn't fit your processes - and you spend years fighting the limitations of the platform. Hastily building your own system - and you spend a six-figure sum on something an off-the-shelf SaaS does for a monthly subscription.
The right decision requires analyzing several factors simultaneously: whether software is your competitive advantage, how much time you have, what budget you have, what your integration needs are, and whether you have a team capable of maintaining your own solution. This quiz will guide you through the process - and give you a concrete recommendation.
When SaaS and when custom software - key differences
COMPARISON TABLE
Criterion | Ready-made SaaS | Custom software |
Launch cost | Low (monthly subscription) | High (one-time implementation) |
Time to first use | Hours-Days | 3-12 months |
Matching your processes | 60-80% (compromises inevitable) | 100% (designed for you) |
Data control | Limited (data at supplier) | Full (own database) |
Cost scaling | Grows linearly with the number of users | Fixed cost after implementation |
Competitive advantage | None (they all use the same thing) | High (unique process/product) |
Vendor lock-in risk | High | No |
IT project risks | Low | Medium-high |
IT team required | None or minimal | Developers or IT partner |
Maintenance cost | Included in the subscription | Separate budget (15-25% per year) |
When to choose a turnkey SaaS?
- The problem you are solving is a common one - there are many proven solutions (CRM, HR, finance, marketing)
- You need a solution that works in days or weeks, not months
- You don't have an internal development team or a permanent IT partner
- Software is an auxiliary tool, not your main product
- A modest annual IT budget - maintaining your own system may exceed SaaS costs
When to build your own software?
- Software IS your product or defines your service - unique software = unique advantage
- You have a specific business process that no SaaS supports well enough
- You process sensitive data (medical, financial, legal) and require full control over the environment
- SaaS subscription costs are high and grow with every user - an in-house system can be cheaper over 3+ years
- Want to build your own SaaS and sell it to other companies
What do the quiz results mean?
Result: Off-the-shelf SaaS - definitely.
Your needs are well-served by existing solutions. Save time and budget - choose a proven SaaS, negotiate a contract and configure integrations. Instead of building, invest in implementation, training and processes.
Result: SaaS with customization (configuration + API)
Most of your needs are covered by off-the-shelf SaaS, but you require integration with existing systems or additional automation. Consider SaaS + integration layer (Zapier, Make, custom API) instead of building from scratch.
Result: Hybrid approach (SaaS + custom modules).
Some of your processes can be handled by SaaS (standard functions), but key elements require custom code. Build a custom module where you have unique value - buy the rest. This is usually the cost-optimal choice.
Result: Custom software
Your requirements or competitive position justify building your own system. Plan the project carefully: start with an MVP (Minimum Viable Product), define the requirements with a product owner, choose a proven technology partner and plan the maintenance budget. dvnt specializes in building web and SaaS applications.
FAQ
How much does it cost to build your own software?
In our web application calculator, an MVP starts from a base of PLN 50,000, a full product with business logic from PLN 145,000 and an enterprise-class system from PLN 500,000 - before features and integrations are added. To the cost of implementation add 15-25% per year for maintenance, upgrades and support.
What is vendor lock-in and how to avoid it?
Vendor lock-in is when you use a SaaS platform so heavily that it becomes very expensive or virtually impossible to migrate to an alternative. To mitigate the risk: negotiate the ability to export data in standard formats, avoid platforms with non-standard API integrations, and document processes independently of the tool.
When is custom software cheaper than SaaS?
The profitability point depends on the number of users and the SaaS rate. For example: with 100 users and a SaaS at PLN 200 per person per month, you pay PLN 240,000 a year. An in-house system costing PLN 300,000 to build plus PLN 60,000 a year to maintain breaks even in under 2 years. Recalculate with your own numbers before making a decision.
How long does it take to implement your own software?
MVP of a simple system: 3-6 months. Full web application with advanced logic: 6-18 months. Plan for a minimum of 3 months for the requirements and design phase before the first line of code appears. Rushing through this phase is the most common cause of budget and schedule overruns.
Is it worth outsourcing software development to an outside company?
Yes, as long as you define the requirements well and retain ownership of the code. Make sure the contract includes: intellectual property rights to the code at the end of the project, access to the code repository, technical documentation and a handover plan for the project. Avoid lock-in at the technology level - the code should be able to be taken over by another developer.
What technologies should I choose to build my own system?
For most companies, we recommend proven, popular technologies with large communities: Next.js (frontend), Node.js (backend), PostgreSQL or MongoDB (database). Popular technologies = easier to hire developers, more ready-made libraries and long-term support. Avoid niche frameworks for critical systems.
The result is a starting point.
In 15 minutes we will check whether an off-the-shelf SaaS or a system of your own is better for your process.